The final reckoning

The end of the year is nigh and time to look back on what we have read or not read. As always the desire is to read more but time is less and the demands on time are unending. We read a lot of fantasy but the ultimate fantasy is to have 3 to 4 uniniterrupted days of binge reading. No phone calls, no door bells, no dog walks, no random obligations. Just get up in the morning with a cup of tea and a book in bed and carry on for the rest of the day in a similar vein.

We have read more than we reviewed this year. Looking back at our posts we suspect this year had considerably less Mondays than usual.

For us it was the year of fantasy murder mysteries. We read two trilogies, one complete and one which has two books out so far. The Witness for the Dead and its sequels by Katherine Addison had us completely absorbed and the first two books in the Shadow of the Leviathan series by Robert Jackson Bennett had us amazed by the scope of the author’s imagination.

We also read Butter by Asako Yuzuki, which is a murder mystery, though not fantasy it is fantastical in many ways. And also still a mystery because there was no solution. It, at least, solved the mystery of which butter to buy if we went to France. We did read quite a few translated books by Japanese and Korean authors this year and enjoyed them. Bookshops these days have whole sections on far eastern authors. The trend seems to have gone beyond Netflix and K dramas.

There were a whole lot of other books that we read during thw year and a few that we reviewed but we have decided that we like the fantasy/murder mystery sub genre. We hope more good ones come along in 2026.

So here’s hoping for good books and a good reading year for everyone. May your coffee/ tea always remain hot and may you rarely be without a book worth reading.

Please stay magical

Enid Blyton was a big deal when we were children. Her school series, The Famous Five books, the magic books were all devoured like food devoured by a famished person just coming off a desert island. Blyton’s books were almost like a rite of passage which we all went through. In those days the occasional lack of political correctness in her characters didn’t seem to bother anyone. We had to beg our parents to buy us new books after finishing whatever we already had ( How times have changed! Now parents would be only too happy if their children asked for more books). One of our very favourite series was the Magic Faraway Tree. Just the idea of climbing a tree and going to a magical land was something that all children dreamt of.

The top of the Faraway Tree had different lands that came to it every once in a while. Which land one would find on a given day was unpredictable. The Tree itself was like an apartment complex with different creatures and peoples who had made parts of the it their home. Each of them being unique in their own way with their unique idiosyncrasies. Into all this came a family of children and the books are about their adventures and the friends they made on the Tree and the lands that came to the top.

Much to our horror we recently saw a trailer for a soon to be released movie based on the beloved books. It looked clichéd and kitsch. Like someone’s idea of what a quaint children’s story should look like, albeit modernised to some extent. The trailer seemed confused about the ‘when’ and ‘where’ of the story. We have had dreadful experiences lately of adaptations of old or classic books. The Netflix adaptation of Anne of Green Gables was horrific as was their Jane Austen’s Persuasion. The lack of creative ideas makes movie makers pick up these old books and modify them into some thing which supposedly just draws inspiration from the original and in the process they ruin the stories for those of us who love the original books, We are also dreading the Netflix Narnia series.

The characters in the books end up becomimg caricatures in the adaptations, while for those of us who read them as children, they were real, some frightening and some who became friends. Perhaps some stories are meant to stay in books and children should be encouraged to read them and visualise the magic rather than watch someone else’s or (now)AI’s interpretation on the screen.

The title has more charm

They say don’t judge a book by its cover as sometimes the books with the most gorgeous covers are the most insipid. The same applies to titles. A Study in Drowning by Ava Reid has an intriguing title with so much possibility and magic within it. Though some of the imagery, language and in particular, some sentences in the book were beautiful enough to keep us reading, the story itself meandered with loose plotlines and weak characterisation. It felt like the story was written in pieces and then shifted around and fitted into a novel.

Effy Sayre lives in a country which is perpetually at war with its neighbour. She is an architecture student at the main University in Llyr. This was a default department for her as the much sought after literature department, which considers itself the upholder of all culture, does not admit women. Effy’s favourite author, Myrridin Emrys, the most celeberated of Llyr’s writers for his book Angharad has died and his estate want to renovate his house into a sort of a memorial. Effy submits the winning design for the competition and finds herself heading to the bottom one hundred of the country, a region replete with myth and superstition.

At Myrridin’s house Effy meets Preston who is a literature student from her University and has been sent to go through and catalogue the late writer’s papers. He is also writing his thesis on the possibilty that Myrridin had not actually written his most famous novel, Angharad. Effy and Preston are initially at loggerheads but then decide to collaborate in order to explore the mystery of the crumbling house, the writer’s personal life and the influence of the Fairy King, whether in Myrridin’s book and also in his life.

The novel addresses the issues of mysoginy which Effy faces continuously and xenophobia – Preston is half Argantian, the country that Llyr is at war with. However both protagonists are bland and behave like bumbling children. By the time reveals are made of past events, the reader has already guessed quite a bit and there is no surprise. In that way the story felt disconnected. The book is apparently YA which is obvious chiefly in the behaviour of the two main characters. Otherwise it is a dark and gothic story with mature themes of mysoginy, prejudice, abandonment, abuse and PTSD. Someow the story did not feel very cohesive, despite beauty in the language and some of the descriptions. There are many loose ends and gaps in the minutiae of the story, it ends in a manner which, in our opinion, did not require a second book. We will leave well enough alone and not read book 2 in the series.

The cheek of Delhi-ites

Winter is here and like Game of Thrones, the north, particularly Delhi and the National Capital Region(NCR) are facing their own version of the white walkers, or in this case the grey. All is smog. Looking out from the plane while landing, it looks like dense fog but is basically a pea souper. We now really know what pea soupers look like outside of Charles Dickens’ books.

Air purifiers cannot be had for love or money in the capital. Not only that but we have heard that the supposed air purifying plants have disappeared from nurseries across the city and its outskirts. We imagine pitched battles over the last mother in law’s tongue plant(dracaena trifasciata) left in the corner of a nursery in a remote part of the NCR. The only interesting things about that plant are its name and its air purifying capabilities, otherwise it has nothing much to recommend it, being quite an ugly plant.

People in Delhi have spider plants crawling all over their rooms and then someone we know commented on the phone that they had heard Bangalore air quality was ‘really bad’! What? What cheek! The Delhi air quality is off the charts and then they tell us that our ‘moderately polluted’ for a few hours in the day is ‘really bad’. Are they trying to make themselves feel better? We have never been so offended! We aren’t stuffing our houses with mother in law’s tongues, spider plants, money plants, zamias and aloe vera plants.

However, we do sense a business opportunity since we have a few of those plants in our gardens and balconies. We are now wondering if we can propogate them and sell online to people in Delhi. We are of course writing this while sitting in an open air restaurant, with decent air quality, while having wood burn oven pizza.

Unusual for Booker

There was a time when we used to eagerly await the Booker longlists and shortlists. In the days prior to easy availability of the internet, the awards lists were a good way of getting an idea of which books to read. And most of the time the books were well worth our time and money. Things slowly started to change and we found ourselves no longer enjoying the Booker winners, let alone the nominated books. We put this down to our own changing tastes as much as the preference of judges for the more dark and edgy literature. In an uncertain world, with the darkness on our tv screens and news, we are no longer inclined to spend our time reading discomforting books.

Recently and much to our surprise we came across A Month in the Country by J L Carr which was shortlisted for the Booker in 1980. It seems impossible now that there was ever a time when such books were considered for prizes. Beyond the protagonist’s recent memory of the trenches of Passchendale during World War 1 and the occasional references to the ugliness of war, the book tells a short story of healing and quiet work carried out in the countryside where everything is connected to the land and the changing seasons.

Tom Birkin returns from the War with his nerves shot and a facial twitch which may or may not get better. Having been trained before the war as a restorer of murals, he gets a job to uncover a whitewashed mural in a rural Yorkshire church. There he meets Moon who has also returned from the war and carrying out excavation work near the church. The descriptions of the countryside and changing colours of summer, the routine of the two outsiders in the area having tea together in the mornings is so redolent of a simpler lifestyle and a simple place. Birkin becomes close to the station master’s family and starts to spend Sundays with them. There is also the Vicar and his wife who make a rather unusual couple. There is the hint of a developing attraction between Birkin and the Vicar’s wife and some gentle ribbing by Moon. More than anything the book is about these two men who have come through something horrific though they don’t talk about it much and find themselves in a place which allows them the slow process of healing.

It is a gentle novel with no dramatic turns other than the revelation of the mural and its colours which are slowly uncovered. The reader is left with a sense of nostalgia and a regret for a way of life which has long gone and can never be re created.

Tiny Escape

Mysore Road from Bangalore was empty on a Wednsday morning. Oh the joy of a constantly moving vehicle – one never experiences this in the city. The sky was clear and the coconut trees looked as if they were standing still against the blue. We were just excited to have run away on a week day with the great idea of going and having lunch in Sapa bakery in Mysore. Since we had been hearing about it from anyone and everyone who had gone to Mysore or travelled through the city.

We know there are a tonnes of other things which Mysore is famous for, like the Palace, the bird sanctuary, Brindavan Gardens etc. But we have seen those many times, albeit many years ago, this trip was planned on the spur od the moment, mainly for foodie reasons. We did however redeem ourselves slightly by visiting the Goddess Chamundeshwari sitting resplendent in her temple on top of the hill

For people visiting Bangalore, Mysore is inevitably on the ‘must visit’ list since it, now with the expressway, is about a two hours away. Typically, when you live next to a tourist destination, you never think of going there as a tourist just to see the place. It doesn’t seem far enough away to qualify for a holiday. But a day spent trying food, at the bakery, was absloutley wonderful. An old and well renovated house with a koi pond in the front, serving delicious meals and really lovely bakery items to take away. And not to mention the sourdough bread which gets sold out before you know it. We bought the last of the stock! Our aim is now to go back and eat three meals since we couldnt taste enough with just one outing. Its only now that we realised we hadnt taken any photos of either the bakery or the patisserie display. We were too busy concentrating on the eating part.

After Sapa we then headed to the market and Guru sweets, the original mysore pak sweet shop and bought some to try later. We must say that the shop deserves its fame even though they take only cash which is odd to say the least, in this day and age. The receipe for the Mysore pak may belong to a different age but our wallets do not. Unfortunately we did not have enough time to go to the covered market which requires detailed inspection, having many narrow lanes to be investigated. We knew we would have to contend with Bangalore evening traffic once we re entered the city and we were anxious to avoid it.

Mysore gave a feeling of space which we no longer get in Bangalore. We dont realise how the high rises stress us out until an afternoon spent in Mysore gave a feeling of calm with most buildings at one or two levels. It was also so much easier to cross the roads. Which is saying a lot when you live in Bangslore.

Food and Murder

In murder mysteries, murderers have often used food to attain their objectives. A little bit of arsenic in the soup, cyanide in the casserole, sleeping pills in the wine or a frozen leg of mutton to bash people over the head. Food becomes an inevitable part of the tale. But in Asako Yuzuki’s Butter (translated by Polly Barton) food is the main character of the story. It isn’t used for the actual murder but as a lure and to ostensibly set up the murder.

Inspired by a true case in Tokyo, the story follows a journalist, Rika Machida, working with a weekly men’s magazine, who decides to interview the elusive Manako Kaiji who is in jail accused of murdering three single, older men. Manako has of course denied the accusations. The protagonist realises that the only way to get the accused to talk to her is to draw her out by discussing food first. As a result, Rika ends up chasing Manako’s food recommendations across the country and also trying Manako’s recipes and cooking for herself and others, which she had never done earlier.

The book also becomes a commentary on the way women in Japan have to conform to bodily ideals, behaviour and social obligations. The same rules do not apply to men. Parallels can be drawn to societies around the world regarding the daily pressures faced by women, whether working or not.

We read the book some time back and tend to remember the food parts much more than the story but there is a strangeness in the characters’ reactions and behaviour which is very typical of most Japanese books. We also had no idea that European cuisine is so popular in Japan and that butter is so valued there. We now want to try Echire butter since the book speaks of it in glowing terms. We tried the simple recipe of slivers of butter on hot rice sprinkled with soya sauce. No matter how much we love Amul butter, it just did not do the trick.

There is no big solving of the murder mystery in this novel which is more about food and detailed descriptions which make the reader want to taste it all. For women, the sense of feeling suffocated by societal pressure and wanting to break free is very easily identifiable. But it is the subtle daily psychological manipulations which people fall prey to that is brought to the fore in the story and the importance of asking for help when you need it.

A murder mystery on narcotics

These days there are all these genre overlaps or combos like Romantasy, science fantasy, horror comedy, space opera etc. The reader basically gets two genres for the price of one. The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett, the first book in The Shadow of the Leviathon series, is a wonderful example of a Murder mystasy. An investigation of murder/s set in a fantasy world. And what a world has been created by Bennett. The Empire of Khanum sits along the sea and there is a big sea wall to prevent the leviathans that come in from the sea and wreak havoc during the rainy season. The Empire is divided into cantons separated by concentric rings of walls going into the centre where the seat of power is concentrated. It is a world which thrives on chemistry and chemical alterations to deal with everything including construction of their towns and structures. The people also induce chemical changes in their biology to enhance abilities. All is done with the intention of working for and protecting the Empire.

Dinios Kol, a fresh recruit, just out of training, is appointed as an assistant to the chief investigator Ana Dolabra who is as madly eccentric as she is brilliant. She blindfolds herself in order to concentrate on the inputs that she gets and also to prevent herself from being distracted by visuals. Dinios has been enhanced to retain information and repeat it in exact detail which makes it ideal for him to carry out the investigations, regurgitate whatever he has absorbed to Ana who then uses her brilliant powers of analyses to deduct what has happened. As such they make a good team.

The novel starts with the horrific death, by way of a tree growing out of a senior army officer at a plush house belonging to the one of the powerful families. Ana and Dinios’s investigation leads them at the beginning of the rainy season, considered the most dangerous season, to a neighbouring canton which is close to the sea wall. The book is a procedural set in this very exotic world. Ana is insanely good at what she does but refuses to tell anyone what her enhancements are. She is also quite insane. Her craziness, combined with the detailed descriptions of the crazy world that they inhabit, and details of various chemicals and human alterations, gives the reader a zapped feeling throughout. almost as if one has vicariously imbibed something. Dinios on the other hand is sane and fastidious in his work and though willing to help Ana with all her crazy demands, he puts his foot down and refrains from indulging her her occasional demand for narcotics.

There is a sense of urgency and fear generated throughout the novel because more people die through the course of the story, a conspiracy is suspected and the sea wall is threatened. As a mystery the book works well and the world building is excellent. Though it is a long book, more than four hundred pages, it means it is meaty enough for the reader to sink their teeth in. at no time does the length seem too much and we would have been happy to have it go on for another few hundred pages just to read some more of Ana. Of course, the sequel was at hand and we made quick work of it.

Murder and Tea

Thara Celehar is not Miss Marple, he does not live in an English village and he is not an elderly woman going around investigating through gossip. But he does love tea and whatever else that comes with it. In the city of Amalo, Thara has been sent to be a Witness for the dead by the Archprelate of his Church. The job is a combination of priest, detective and bureaucrat. He has the capability of sensing the last thoughts and feelings of those recently deceased and is therefore often called upon, soon after any death which is questionable. The Witness for the Dead by Katherine Addison is set in the same world as The Goblin Emperor and though Thara was there in the earlier book, The Witness for the Dead is more of an off shoot and not a sequel and can be read independently. It is the first book in The Cemetaries of Amalo trilogy.

The novel starts with the death of an opera singer in mysterious circumstances and Thara is called upon to witness for her. That becomes the main investigation carried out by Thara but there are others throughout the book which require his special skill set. Like The Goblin Emperor, there is a lot of politics and Thara has to gingerly feel his way through the dynamics between the Prince of Amalo, the church in Amalo and the Archpelate based at the capital.

The book seems slow paced, perhaps because of the detailed world building but is gripping and at no time does the reader feel there is too much being thrown at them. Addison has created a whole world inhabited by elves and goblins living in a steam punk environment. There are a plethora of invented names and titles, some quite difficult to pronounce. It speaks to her genius that the reader does not get put off by it all. She describes the city and streets in such detail that the reader feels it is real and that they are living in it. Along with Thara we are told which streets to take for a particular destination, which bridges will be less crowded at the hour, the tram routes to take and the most popular teahouses along the way.

Thara and those of his world live in the tea shops. It is comforting to read about the different varieties of tea and which teas can be had at certain times of day and which to suit different moods. Ultimately it is the decency of the protagonist and the friendships he forms in this new city, including with the Director of the opera, while dealing with his own grief, which provide a quiet warmth to the whole book. While he has the ability to sense the last emotions of the recently dead and therefore witness for them, it does not always throw up clear answers. The rest of the story is pure investigative work and Thara takes his job very seriously as he feels it is a duty bestowed on him by his God Ulis. Though the subject may be morbid, the gentle conversations that Thara has during the investigation, his compassion and his strict and sometimes ruthless adherence to doing the right thing make the novel kindly rather than grim.

The book is quiet and enjoyable for those who love fantasy, murder mysteries and tea.

Fire and Ice

No, it’s not Game of Thrones and it is more fun though a lot shorter. In a world gone mad with wars, bombardments, plane crashes, ships on fire, people with guns running around shooting people, we have to somehow stop hyperventilating. The only thing we feel like doing is sticking our head in the sand or pulling the covers over our head and refusing to get out of bed. Since neither option is really available to us, the next best thing is disappear into the virtual pages of a book. Not just any book but a middle grade book which has dragons and magic.

Ember and the Ice Dragons by Heather Fawcett has all the ingredients for a first rate escapist dish. We had read the more adult fantasy written by the same author but felt the times required something less intense for us to read. Ember’s father is a stormancer magician who keeps getting fired from his position at the university where he teaches but because he is so brilliant they hire him back almost immediately. Ember is an unsual 12 year old with a cat who can speak and an Aunt who is in charge of the research station at Antarctica.

Ember decides that in the interest of all concerned, it is best that she goes and spends some time with her Aunt in the snowy landscape. She lands in Antarctica with her luggage and a doorknob called Montgomery. The advantages of having a magician father means that she can attach Montgomery to any door and go back home to see her father whenever she is homesick. We have decided we would really, really like to have our own Montgomery. In Antarctica Ember inadvertently releases magic amongst the penguins who are then able to go around zapping people with bursts of electricity. This was so hyterical that we felt the entire book was elevated by just that one idea. We never thought penguins could win over Dragons. But the ice Dragons in Antarctica are also quite full of character, hoarding not gold but riddles that then need to be solved.

Ember makes friends and enemies and sets off on a quest to prevent bad people from hunting Dragons. The book is cute, funny, has a brave and spunky protagonist who, upon meeting one of the hunters decides to make him her arch enemy. The penguins are fabulous as are the beleaguered Dragons and Ember’s Aunt and father are absolutely the best. Like we said, very escapist .